EFF: Closed, Proprietary, Felonious: The Toxic Rainbow of Locked Technology
Closed, Proprietary, Felonious: The Toxic Rainbow of Locked Technology When is software free? Is it enough that the software be licensed under a free or open license? What about patents? Software as a service? Trade secrets? What about DRM? Is software ever free? There’s a saying in the software freedom movement: “if you can’t open it, it’s not yours.” That is, if you can’t run it, study it, improve it, and distribute it , then your technology isn’t free. It’s closed, proprietary, un-free. When software was first invented, it wasn’t considered to be a copyrightable work; it was something more like math, a collection of utilitarian facts. A series of acts of Congress and court decisions in the 1970s and 1980s gradually and firmly moved software into the realm of copyrightable “literary works” and in reaction, Richard Stallman started the Free Software movement, with the goal of halting and reversing the encroachment of un-freedom on software. The early free software licenses fo...