EFF: Judge Dodges Legality of NSA Mass Spying, Citing Secrecy Claims
Judge Dodges Legality of NSA Mass Spying, Citing Secrecy Claims EFF’s case challenging NSA spying, Jewel v. NSA, has come further than any case trying to end the government’s mass surveillance programs. Our clients have survived multiple efforts by the government to end the case, and they continue to push for their day in court. As a result, we’re no stranger to overcoming legal obstacles thrown our way. The latest obstacle came Thursday, when the court hearing our long-running case challenging NSA spying ruled that the lawsuit should be dismissed on account of the government’s argument that to proceed further would jeopardize national security. Athough we are disappointed that the case was dismissed on the basis of the government’s state secrecy arguments, we are not surprised. T he Justice Department insists that our legal fight against this spying is bound by a Catch-22 : no one can sue unless the court first determines that they were certainly touched by the vas...